fbpx Skip to content
Richard Serra
The United States Courts Are Partial to Government, 1989

Artwork Info

Artwork title
The United States Courts Are Partial to Government
Artist name
Richard Serra
Date created
1989
Classification
drawing
Medium
paintstick on paper
Dimensions
105 in. × 185 3/8 in. (266.7 cm × 470.85 cm)
Date acquired
1994
Credit
The Doris and Donald Fisher Collection at the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art and the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art
Copyright
© Richard Serra / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York
Permanent URL
https://www.sfmoma.org/artwork/94.449
Artwork status
Not on view at this time.

Audio Stories

How Serra went head-to-head with the U.S. government

Show TranscriptHide Transcript

transcripts

RICHARD SERRA:

The horizontal diptychs are masses in relation to each other. They’re not about compositions or figure-ground. They emphasize the comparison of different weights in juxtaposition. I usually start a body of work and the work takes on its own needs. It has its own momentum, and the momentum of one work leads to the next, which leads to the next work. And at a point, the work becomes internally critical of itself. You don’t know if the first or second piece is resolved until you see the seventh or eighth. Then after a period, the internal logic drives the work.

The double-panel drawings coincide pretty much with the government’s destroying of Tilted Arc. They were my pushback series. You never know what motivates. Anger and fear are often as motivating as reinforcement and support.

 

NARRATOR:

Tilted Arc, a 12 foot high, 120 foot long arc of CorTen Steel, was a site-specific sculpture that was commissioned by the United States government and conceived for Federal Plaza in lower Manhattan. Soon after its installation, some government officials who worked in Federal Plaza began to petition for its removal. In 1985 William Diamond, the regional administrator for the General Services Administration, convened hearings to determine whether it should remain in place. He hand-picked the five-person committee in charge of the hearing, selected two of his own employees and appointed himself chair. Serra argued that because the sculpture was site-specific, to remove it was to destroy it – and that destroying it was not within the government’s ownership rights. After a two-day hearing, the panel voted 4-1 to remove the sculpture from the plaza. Serra challenged the decision in court twice, but on March 15, 1989, the sculpture was destroyed. Since then Serra has been a major advocate of artists’ rights to protect their work.

Read MoreCollapse

Other Works by Richard Serra

See other works by Richard Serra

Please note that artwork locations are subject to change, and not all works are on view at all times. If you are planning a visit to SFMOMA to see a specific work of art, we suggest you contact us at collections@sfmoma.org to confirm it will be on view.

Only a portion of SFMOMA's collection is currently online, and the information presented here is subject to revision. Please contact us at collections@sfmoma.org to verify collection holdings and artwork information. If you are interested in receiving a high resolution image of an artwork for educational, scholarly, or publication purposes, please contact us at copyright@sfmoma.org.

This resource is for educational use and its contents may not be reproduced without permission. Please review our Terms of Use for more information.