Can We Imagine an Anti-Racist Future?

by Mark C. Jerng

The September 8, 2016, opening of Desirée Holman’s Sophont in Action sparked a question: Can we imagine an anti-racist future? Little did we know that exactly two months later this question would become entirely enmeshed with the enormous weight of the United States presidential election result. An enormous weight not because the election marked a step backward, but rather because it marked what the historian Ibram X. Kendi calls “the progression of racism.” If there has been progress in the challenging of racial inequalities, there has simultaneously been racist progress into new forms, new modes of thought, and new and far-reaching policies that structure the future of education, housing, finance, the law. Racism is not a “backward” idea, an attempt to return to past forms of inequality. It is forward-looking, laying claim to our capacity to imagine the future.

A group of children standing in a field

Desirée Holman, Sophont (still), 2015; photo: Charles Villyard

This is why imagining an anti-racist future is so challenging. It does not just entail imagining the eradication of past forms of racism. Nor does it mean imagining a colorblind world. Indeed, in the still-reigning common sense of liberal multiculturalism, replete with its diversity initiatives and sensitivity training, populating a world with a diverse set of actors and even challenging assumptions of white privilege is enough. Popular films and visual culture are filled with images of multiracial futures in which race seemingly does not matter or racism has been recognized as a fallacy. But all too often this visual culture — the places where we often go to learn how to imagine the future — recode the appearance of diversity within new logics of racial discrimination. Imagining a multiracial future is not the same as imagining an antiracist future. The latter requires challenging the progress of racism as it proliferates and transforms our very capacity to imagine the future.

That is why the science fictional, speculative, and fantastical imaginations of world building in the work of Desirée Holman, Naomi Rincón Gallardo, and Jacolby Satterwhite are so vital now and going forward. World building involves creating not just scenarios, but the background rules and landscapes that make possible certain existences and not others. Think of J. R. R. Tolkien’s Middle Earth, or, better, the dystopian world of Octavia Butler’s Parable of the Sower (1993), which now provides such a canny reflection of our own times. It is the science-fictional imagination that provides the powerful context for these performances-in-progress.

Naomi Rincón Gallardo, The Formaldehyde Trip

Naomi Rincón Gallardo, The Formaldehyde Trip, 2016 (still); photo: Fabiola Torres Alzaga

The tradition of literary speculation is a mixed bag to be sure, ranging from pretending that racism is not a problem, to imagining futures populated only by white people, to reimagining imperial and colonial violence at ever greater scales. While these imagined futures often carry the promise of engaging with problems of racial difference in the form of imagining other species, aliens, et cetera, they all too often reproduce our own world’s deep rifts of racialized economic inequality. But the speculative futures of Butler, Nalo Hopkinson, Samuel Delany, Larissa Lai, Nnedi Okorafor, Ken Liu, Jewelle Gomez, and other emerging writers challenge the usual ways of confronting difference and structures of inequality. In her Xenogenesis trilogy, for example, Butler’s main character is forced to procreate with an alien species and must grapple with the imagination of a future very different from the possibilities that she previously envisioned.

Artwork image of Jacolby Satterwhite's Reifying Desire 6 (still), 2014.

Jacolby Satterwhite, Reifying Desire 6 (still), 2014.

In the hands of Holman, Gallardo, and Satterwhite, world building is a technique to inhabit spaces and times differently and to interrupt the ways in which we inhabit our own world. All three artists exploit the anachronistic and the incongruous — putting together what otherwise might belong in different times and spaces — in order to perform this imagination and interruption. If our usual routines are already saturated by the prospective visions of what could or might happen along racist lines, then their work invites us to enter divergent spaces in the hope of creating other possibilities of world building.


Mark C. Jerng

Mark C. Jerng

Mark C. Jerng is an Associate Professor of English and the Director of Graduate Studies at the University of California, Davis. His research on critical race studies and popular fictions of science fiction and fantasy will be published in his forthcoming book, Racial Worldmaking: The Power of Popular Fiction (Fordham University Press, 2017).

Read more

Imagining the Future: Race, Language, and Movement in Performance in Progress

Performance in Progress returns March 16–19, 2017, featuring works by Desirée Holman, Naomi Rincón Gallardo, and Jacolby Satterwhite. All three artists’ performances draw on the visuals and narratives of science fiction and fantasy to imagine alternative futures. Here, the scholar Mark C. Jerng describes the artists’ manifestations of an anti-racist future, LeiLani Nishime ponders race-related questions in Holman’s work specifically, and Naomi Rincón Gallardo and Sophia Wang discuss choreography as language.

Desirée Holman's Sophont in Context

Desirée Holman’s Sophont (2015) is a multichannel video commissioned by SFMOMA’s Performance department for Performance in Progress, a program that invites artists working in live idioms to create new works for the museum space, with an eye to the interests and histories of the Bay Area. Sophont features three groups of performers: Time Travelers, Ecstatic Dancers, and Indigo Children. The term sophont refers to an intelligent being, human or nonhuman, capable of extraordinary reasoning and introspection. It was first used in the science fiction of Poul Anderson to describe such beings. It is also associated with the term “sentient being,” meaning one with the ability to feel and perceive, which arises frequently in Buddhism.

Please Enter the Mind of Jacolby Satterwhite

Jacolby Satterwhite is taking SFMOMA visitors inside his head, literally. He calls it a virtual reality (VR) performance. Read on to learn more about Satterwhite’s practice and his Performance in Progress residency.

Naomi Rincón Gallardo in Collaboration

Mexico City–based artist Naomi Rincón Gallardo collaborated with several Bay Area musicians and artists to create her new performance and video work, The Formaldehyde Trip. Learn more about Gallardo and the artists who helped her create the piece’s DIY aesthetics.

Gallardo will be live at SFMOMA September 29–October 2, 2016, as Performance in Progress presents a behind-the-scenes look at The Formaldehyde Trip, a visual album that weaves together Mesoamerican cosmologies, feminist activism and theory, and indigenous women’s struggles for their territories.

Projects + Perspectives

Find out more about the people and stories that make up SFMOMA. We love what we do and want to share it with you!